The CEU Philosophy Department cordially invites you to a talk
by
Ruth Weintraub (Tel-Aviv University)
on
What If Scpeticism Is True? (An Exercise in Reliabilism)
NOTE: FRIDAY!! 17 Oct 2008, 3.30 PM, Zrinyi 14, Room 412
ABSTRACT
Our ability to track objects as they undergo change suggests very strongly that we both
perceive, and conceive of, objects as things distinct from their properties, as enduring
individual substances. This notion that objects are individual substances, rather than
simply co-instantiated collections of properties we can call the intrinsic concept of
objects. An alternative view, that objects are collections of properties we can call the
relational conception of objects. On the relational view when (essential?) properties
change, so do objects. I apply some lessons from debates about the nature of objects and
our perception of them in order to understand the nature of the experience involved in
delusions of misidentification. These delusions report the experience of seeing someone
who is perceptually indistinguishable from a familiar person but is not the familiar
person. On the relational conception of objects this would be impossible. Yet the standard
way of explaining these delusions within cognitive neuropsychiatry assumes the relational
conception. Not only that but the standard view also assumes that experience of seeing a
particular relational object (in this case a person) is partly constituted by affective
experience. This combination of assumptions leads to problems whose resolution is the aim
of the final section of this paper
Kriszta Biber
Department Coordinator
Philosophy Department
Tel: 36-1-327-3806
Fax: 36-1-327-3072
E-mail: biberk(a)ceu.hu
Show replies by date