The CEU Department of Philosophy cordially invites you to a talk
(as part of its Departmental Colloquium series)
by
Michel ter Hark (University of Groningen)
on
'Wittgenstein on the Necker cube: shifting aspects between the Tractatus and the
Philosophical Investigations.'
Tuesday, 22 March, 2010, 4.30 PM, Zrinyi 14, Room 412
ABSTRACT
This talk is about the relation between a very specific remark in the Tractatus, 5.5432
about seeing an ambiguous 3D cube, and Wittgenstein's later writings on aspect seeing.
In my talk I argue in the first place that a sound reading of 5.5432 does not commit
Wittgenstein to a form of (sense datum) realism, as e.g. Hintikka supposes. Instead I
argue that at 5.5432 Wittgenstein applies his theory of the proposition to dissolve
problems in the theory of perceptual judgements in a way analogous to his critique of
Russell's theory of judgement. In the second part of my lecture I try to explain why
Wittgenstein was so much interested in this and related phenomena. The answer to this
question will reveal a 'therapeutic' or 'antimetaphysical' interest. There
is something about such phenomena that in particular triggers the philosophical mind to
hypostatise 'objects' which serve to explain them. Finally, I argue that in the
Tractatus Wittgenstein himself succumbed to this explanatorily illusion and that this is
part of the motive of his later writings on the subject.
Show replies by date