The CEU Department of Philosophy cordially invites you to a talk
(as part of its Departmental Colloquium series)
by
Philip Goff
(University of Hertfordshire)
on
A Priori Physicalism and Lonely Ghosts
Tuesday, 19 October, 2010, 4.30 PM, Zrinyi 14, Room 412
ABSTRACT
A priori physicalism is the view that conscious states are a priori entailed by physical
states. Cartesian doubt is a well known process whereby one doubts the existence of
anything that it is epistemically possible to doubt. At the end of Cartesian doubt, the
doubter finds herself coherently conceiveing of a state of affairs in which: (i) she is
the only thing that exists, (ii) she exists as a thing whose nature is exhausted by
conscious experience. In other words, she ends up conceiving of herself as a 'lonely
ghost'. I will argue that the fact that we can coherently conceive of lonely ghosts is
inconsistent with any of the forms of a priori physicalism on offer in the philosophy of
mind literature. The two samples of a priori physicalism I will discuss are: David
Lewis's brand of analytic functionalism and Fred Dretske's naturalistic
representationalism. I will finish by outlining a respect in which this argument against a
priori physicalism is dialectically stronger than the knowledge argument or the zombie
conceivability argument.
Kriszta Biber
Department Coordinator
Philosophy Department
Tel: 36-1-327-3806
Fax: 36-1-327-3072
E-mail: biberk(a)ceu.hu
Show replies by date