György
Gergely
Institute
for Psychological Research
Hungarian
Academy of Sciences
Learning
‘about’
versus learning ‘from other minds:
The role
of ostensive
cues in triggering pedagogical knowledge transfer
in human
infants
Tuesday, 28
November, 2006, 5 PM
CEU
Department of Philosophy, 1051 Budapest, Zrínyi u. 14, 4th floor, rm.
412.
Abstract
By
the end of their first year human infants start
to exhibit a number of species-unique social cognitive competences
(such as
social referencing, imitative learning of novel means, or
proto-declarative
pointing) that involve triadic interactions in ostensive communicative
cuing
contexts. The currently dominant interpretation of these early
social-cognitive
phenomena assumes that their primary function is to serve social
motives (such as intersubjective sharing of mental states).
In this talk I shall contrast this view with an alternative
interpretation
based on the theory of human ‘pedagogy’ (Csibra & Gergely, 2006;
Gergely
& Csibra, 2005, 2006) which assumes that ostensively cued triadic interactions serve primarily the epistemic function of transferring new
and relevant cultural knowledge about referents to infants. The theory
argues
that others’ referential manifestations during triadic interactions are
typically framed by specific types of ostensive-communicative
cues for which infants show early sensitivity and preference. These
include
eye-contact, contingent turn-taking reactivity, the prosodic intonation
pattern
of motherese, and addressing infants
by their own name. Such ostensive cues trigger in
infants the interpretation that
the other exhibits a communicative intention addressed to them to
manifest new
and relevant information for them to fast learn about the referent. It
is
hypothesized that ostensive cues can act as an ‘interpretation switch’
directing infants to construe others’ referential knowledge
manifestations as
pedagogical ‘teaching’ events. I shall review recent evidence from
studies of
relevance-guided selective imitative learning and of infants’
differential
interpretation of others’ referential emotion expressions during the
second
year that provide convergent empirical support for the hypothesized
interpretation-modulating role of ostensive cuing in early infancy.